Potting soil and garden soil both have a place in the garden. The main thing to think about is where the soil will go.
Use potting soil in pots and other containers. Use garden soil in the ground and in large beds. Plants in pots need soil that drains well and holds air, and potting mix is made for that job.
Neither one is better overall. The differences matter when you decide how to use each one. Read on to learn how they differ and when to use each.


Major differences between garden soil and potting soil
Garden soil is best in the ground. Potting soil is best in containers. Garden soil is natural earth, made over a long time from rock and from plant and animal matter. Potting soil is a mix of ingredients blended in a factory.
They are made of different things. Potting soil is a blend of materials like peat moss, perlite, and compost (read all about potting soil ingredients here). Garden soil is made of tiny bits of rock, decayed plant and animal matter, and living things.
Here are the main differences between potting soil and garden soil.
Garden soil is mined from the ground, while potting soil is assembled in a manufacturing plant
Garden soil can be dug up from a backyard. If you have a yard, you have garden soil. You can also buy it in bulk from local suppliers.
Potting mix is bought from a garden center, nursery, or big box store. It is a commercial product, and its ingredients may come from far away.
Material composition of garden soil vs. potting mix
Garden soil is made of weathered minerals, decayed plant and animal matter, and many living organisms. It varies a lot from place to place.
University of Maryland Extension says commercial soilless mixes “are typically comprised of ingredients such as sphagnum peat moss, perlite, vermiculite, composted bark, compost, and coconut coir.” It adds that they include small amounts of lime and fertilizer.
So the two share very few materials. Read the bag to know what you’re getting.
Void space for roots, air, and drainage in garden soil versus potting soil
The spaces between soil particles matter as much as the particles. Air and water fill those spaces, and roots need both.
UMD Extension explains that irrigation water moves through the pore spaces and pushes out the air. If excess water can’t drain away, fresh air can’t get in and roots suffocate.
Garden soil in the ground has pore space, but packed soil has less. Compacted soil is hard for roots to grow in.
Potting mix is made to hold air and water in a pot. UMD Extension says garden soils are too dense to allow good air and water movement in a container.
Weight and density of garden soil and potting mix
Garden soil is heavy and dense. Soil rich in organic matter holds a lot of water and stays moist for a long time, but it can become compacted.
Potting mix is light and fluffy. Pots dry out faster than garden beds. A bag of good potting mix weighs much less than the same size bag of garden soil, though a soaked mix gets heavy.

Nutrients in garden soil vs. potting soil
Healthy garden soil holds nutrients from decayed plant matter, and it keeps getting more as organic matter breaks down.
Potting mix has a limited supply of nutrients, so container plants need feeding. The carrots I grow in the ground always taste better than the ones I grow in potting mix. But the potted ones grow straighter! There are many ways to add nutrients like nitrogen to the soil.

Packaging for potting soil vs. garden soil
Potting mix is almost always sold in plastic bags. Small bags often reseal, which is handy for storage. Large amounts come in compressed bales wrapped in plastic.
Garden soil is more of a bulk product. You can buy it in bags, but you can also buy it by the truckload, with no plastic.
Either way, find out what the soil is made of. Read the bag, or ask the supplier.
Living organisms in garden soil vs. potting soil
Garden soil is full of life. Bacteria, fungi, earthworms, and insects all live in it, and this soil food web keeps outdoor soil healthy.
Potting mix has far less life in it. Iowa State Extension says high quality mixes are free of plant disease organisms and weed seeds. Most of us don’t want to bring bugs indoors, so that is a plus for houseplants. Some mixes add helpful mycorrhizal fungi.
Seed content: Garden soil vs. potting soil
Garden soil holds lots of seeds, and many of them sprout. That means weeds. UMD Extension says commercial soilless mixes are “generally free of weeds, insects, and diseases.”
Watering techniques for different types of soil
Potting mix is light, so water it gently with a watering can. UMD Extension says soilless mixes tend to repel water when dry, so work water in until the mix is wet through. Garden soil can take a hose or sprinkler. Drip lines work well for both.

Cost considerations for potting soil or garden soil
Potting mix costs more than garden soil, because it is blended from several ingredients.
Garden soil may cost about the same by the bag, but it is much cheaper in bulk. If you need a lot, buy garden soil by the yard.
Contamination of potting soil with garden soil
Both can carry problems. Garden soil can pick up pollutants from its surroundings. Potting mixes vary in quality, so choose a good one.
Ask where your soil comes from. Was it dug near you? Is it made from compost from a large feedlot far away? It’s worth asking.
Range of parameters between garden soil and potting mix
Garden soil varies a lot in pH, salt, and even metals. Good potting mix is much more consistent. UMD Extension says commercial soilless mixes have a pH of about 6.2.

When to use potting soil in your garden
Plants in pots have different needs than plants in the ground. Use potting mix for indoor plants and for pots outdoors. UMD Extension says commercial soilless mixes are an excellent choice for containers.
Pots filled with potting mix are lighter to move. The mix also holds air and water well for roots that have only a small space to grow.
Use potting mix in planters, hanging baskets, window boxes, and other containers. It drains well and lets air reach the roots. Roots need both air and water, so don’t let pots sit soggy or dry out.
There are mixes for many uses, such as cactus, orchid, succulent, and seed-starting mixes, and mixes for organic vegetables.
For starting seeds, use a fresh seed-starting mix. Seedlings are easy prey for disease, and a clean mix gives them a good start.
Potting mix is great for apartments, or anywhere you need only a little soil. It’s easy to buy in small amounts. Iowa State Extension says poor quality mixes are often inexpensive, black, heavy, and don’t drain well. Choose a light mix that drains.


When to use garden soil instead of potting mix
Raised beds are a good place for garden soil. It’s much cheaper in bulk, and you can mix in other ingredients for healthy plants. Some of the best raised bed gardens are tall, which makes them easy to use but means they need a lot of soil.
For our raised beds, we used a trailer load of OMRI-certified garden soil mixed with lots of homemade compost and a few big bags of perlite. You can buy perlite on its own and mix it into the soil to make it less dense so it holds more air. Blending your own mix takes work, but it’s worth it.
Garden soil is also good for leveling lawns or filling low spots. Grass grows well in it, and you won’t have white perlite bits floating up in your lawn.
A lab soil test tells you a lot about your garden soil. It shows the pH and any nutrient shortages, so you can choose the right fertilizer.


Can I use garden soil in a container garden?
You can, but it’s not a good idea if you can get a good potting mix. Iowa State University Extension says garden soil alone is not a good growing medium for containers.
Iowa State Extension says garden soil compacts in a container, which leads to poor drainage and air flow. It also pulls away from the sides of the pot as it dries, which makes watering hard. Pots full of garden soil are also very heavy.
What about huge outdoor planters that would take too much potting mix to fill? You have some options.
Iowa State Extension says you can make a homemade potting mix from equal parts garden soil, sphagnum peat moss, and perlite. UMD Extension says topsoil should only be added to very large containers and should not be more than 10% of the volume. You can also set empty pots upside down in the bottom to take up space. Watch that the planter doesn’t get top-heavy.
If you do use garden soil in a container, use it outdoors, not indoors. Break it up first and mix in perlite and compost. Watch for weeds and soil-borne disease.
Will a plant grow in a pot full of garden soil? It might. Would it be happier in potting mix? Most likely.

Can I put potting soil in a garden bed?
Yes. Seedlings grown in potting mix go into the garden all the time. Leftover potting mix can be mixed into garden soil, where it helps lighten heavy soil. That’s much better than throwing it out. I put my extra potting mix in the compost, and it has always worked well for me.
The only time I don’t reuse old potting mix in the garden is if the plants in it had a disease. Even then, I don’t throw it in the trash. It can go through a hot compost pile before reuse. Your city may have a yard waste program that hot composts. You can also use doubtful mix to fill a low spot in a back corner.

Potting soil vs garden soil FAQ
Can I use garden soil in pots?
Iowa State Extension says garden soil alone is not a good growing medium for containers, because it compacts and does not drain well.
How do I make my own potting mix with garden soil?
Iowa State Extension suggests equal parts garden soil, sphagnum peat moss, and perlite.
Can I put leftover potting soil in my garden?
Yes. Mix it into garden soil or add it to the compost. Hot compost it first if the old plants had a disease.
Is potting soil sterile?
Not quite. UMD Extension says commercial soilless mixes are “generally free of weeds, insects, and diseases.”
Seed companies I like
These are the seed companies I order from for my own garden.
- Botanical Interests: beautiful packets with growing notes printed inside
- High Mowing Organic Seeds: certified organic, grown in Vermont
- True Leaf Market: big selection of hybrids, microgreens, and cover crops
Some links earn me a commission at no cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.



Leave a Reply