The best red peonies for most gardens are ‘Karl Rosenfield’, ‘Kansas’, ‘Red Charm’, ‘Félix Crousse’, and ‘Buckeye Belle’. The American Peony Society registry describes ‘Karl Rosenfield’ (1908) as a bright crimson double, and ‘Kansas’ (1940) as a clear red double that fades very little. ‘Red Charm’ is an early, bomb-shaped hybrid, and ‘Buckeye Belle’ is a very early, dark red semi-double. Herbaceous peonies grow in Zones 3 to 8 and need 6 to 8 hours of direct sun, per Wisconsin Extension.
Want the earliest red? Pick ‘Buckeye Belle’, ‘Red Charm’, or ‘Cherry Hill’. Want stems that stand up on their own? Choose ‘Kansas’ or ‘Old Faithful’. Cutting for vases? Try ‘Felix Supreme’, which the registry calls a model cut flower. Short border? Look at the Itoh hybrids ‘Hillary’ and ‘Lollipop’, which stay under 30 inches.
Red peonies bring rich color and drama to spring gardens. These bold blooms range from deep crimson to bright scarlet, with flower forms from simple singles to lush doubles. Below are 25+ red peony varieties with notes from the American Peony Society registry, which records each cultivar’s breeder, year, and flower form.


‘Karl Rosenfield’ peony
Karl Rosenfield was bred by Rosenfield and introduced in 1908. The American Peony Society registry describes a large, very bright crimson double with waved outer petals and strong stems. It blooms midseason and has no scent. Older growers called it the best red variety, and it works for cutting and the garden. It is a cultivar of Paeonia lactiflora.
‘Kansas’ peony
Kansas is a bright, clear red double bred by Myron Bigger in Kansas in 1940. The American Peony Society registry notes that it fades very little, blooms every year, and has strong stems about 30 inches tall. It won the American Peony Society Gold Medal in 1957.

‘Red Charm’ peony
Red Charm is an early hybrid of Paeonia officinalis and P. lactiflora bred by Lyman Glasscock in 1944. The American Peony Society registry describes a large, bomb-shaped, rich red double on tall, stiff stems. It won the Gold Medal in 1956.
‘Félix Crousse’ peony
Félix Crousse is a large crimson double bred in France and introduced in 1881. The American Peony Society registry notes weak stems that need support and little fragrance. It blooms late midseason and is one of the most reliable reds for color.

Fernleaf peony
Fernleaf peony (Paeonia tenuifolia) is an early-blooming species with crimson petals and bright yellow stamens. The finely cut foliage resembles fern fronds and stays attractive throughout the growing season. It blooms ahead of most garden peonies. Fernleaf peonies grow well in well-drained soil and tolerate dry conditions once established.
‘Buckeye Belle’ peony
Buckeye Belle is a very early semi-double bred by Mains in Ohio in 1956. The American Peony Society registry describes dark red guard petals around yellow anthers and a glossy finish that is rare in a dark flower. It won the Gold Medal in 2010.

‘Henry Bockstoce’ peony
Henry Bockstoce is a tall, dark red double hybrid with a rose-form center, introduced in 1955. The American Peony Society registry notes good, strong stems.
‘Felix Supreme’ peony
Felix Supreme is a large, full double in rich ruby red, introduced by Kriek in 1955. The American Peony Society registry says its stem and flower meet all the needs of a cut flower. It blooms midseason.
‘Old Faithful’ peony
Old Faithful is a double red hybrid from Glasscock and Falk, introduced in 1964. The American Peony Society registry notes heavy substance, large plants, and late bloom for a hybrid. It won the Gold Medal in 1997. This variety works well in perennial borders where consistent performance matters.
‘Kirinmaru’ peony
Kirinmaru is sold as a bicolor peony with white petals streaked in red. It is not in the American Peony Society registry under that name, so check the nursery listing for its form and height.
‘Benjamin Franklin’ peony
Benjamin Franklin is a dark crimson double from the Brand nursery in Minnesota, introduced in 1907. The American Peony Society registry describes very tall plants with blooms held high above the leaves. The flowers are small with little scent, so it works best for garden color.
‘Black Beauty’ peony
Black Beauty is a dark red Paeonia lactiflora introduced in 1924. The American Peony Society registry lists it as a single, so it shows its stamens. Some nurseries sell other dark peonies under this name, so check the flower form before buying.
‘Victoire de la Marne’ peony
Victoire de la Marne is a very large purplish red double with lighter edges, introduced in France in 1915. The American Peony Society registry notes a strong, unpleasant odor, so keep it out of vases.
‘Command Performance’ peony
Command Performance is a cardinal red hybrid introduced in 1996. The American Peony Society registry describes a 7-inch globe with a strong fragrance on 30 to 32 inch plants. It has one bud per stem and grows at a moderate rate.
‘Prince of Darkness’ peony
Prince of Darkness is a dark, black-maroon red lactiflora from the Brand nursery, introduced in 1907. The American Peony Society registry warns that it burns in sun and is now scarce.
‘Rachel’ peony
Rachel is a bright garnet-red lactiflora from Terry, introduced in 1900. The American Peony Society registry describes medium-size, semi-rose flowers on upright plants, good for both the garden and cutting.
‘Red Sarah Bernhardt’ peony
Red Sarah Bernhardt is a nursery name for a large, red double lactiflora. It is not in the American Peony Society registry under that name, so check the seller for its size and scent.
‘Diana Parks’ peony
Diana Parks is a carmine red hybrid of P. officinalis bred by W.S. Bockstoce in 1942. The American Peony Society registry describes one row of guard petals around a full center of narrow, cut petals, a pleasing fragrance, and plants up to 42 inches tall.
‘Peter Brand’ peony
Peter Brand is a dark red double lactiflora from Abraham Brand, introduced before 1937, per the American Peony Society registry.
‘Hillary’ Itoh peony
Hillary is an intersectional (Itoh) hybrid of herbaceous and tree peonies, introduced by Roger Anderson in 1999. The American Peony Society registry describes a semi-double to double red and yellow blend, with the yellow fading to cream on the outer petals. Plants reach 24 to 26 inches. It won the Gold Medal in 2020.
‘Lollipop’ Itoh peony
Lollipop is an Itoh hybrid from Roger Anderson, introduced in 1999. The American Peony Society registry describes semi-double to double yellow flowers with red candy stripes on 26 to 29 inch plants that carry many flowers.
‘Shima-Nishiki’ tree peony
Shima-Nishiki is a historic Japanese tree peony (Paeonia suffruticosa). The red petals have cream-white streaks. It is listed in the American Peony Society registry. Tree peonies keep woody stems through winter, per Wisconsin Extension.
‘Cherry Hill’ peony
Cherry Hill is a very early double from Thurlow, introduced in 1915. The American Peony Society registry describes a rich, dark crimson with a glistening sheen, yellow stamens, and very tall plants with strong stems. The flowers keep well when cut.
‘François Ortegat’ peony
François Ortegat is a Belgian heirloom from Parmentier, introduced in 1850. The American Peony Society registry describes a semi-double dark red with a pleasant scent and purple, wiry stems.
‘Belgravia’ peony
Belgravia is sold as a red-pink double that opens red and matures to deep pink. It is not in the American Peony Society registry under that name, so check the nursery listing for its size.

Growing red peonies
Red peonies need full sun, which Wisconsin Extension defines as 6 to 8 hours of direct light. Plant them in well-drained soil with the buds (eyes) 1 to 2 inches below the surface. Wisconsin notes that peonies set deeper than 2 inches often fail to bloom. Space plants 3 to 5 feet apart. September and October are the best months to move or divide them.
Herbaceous peonies grow in USDA Zones 3 to 8. Peonies planted too deep or in too much shade often fail to bloom. Check planting depth if an established peony stops flowering.
Peony care tips
Water new peonies on a steady schedule in their first season. Drought tolerance improves as the plants age. Avoid heavy nitrogen, which Wisconsin says pushes leaves at the expense of blooms.
Many double-flowered red peonies have heavy blooms that need support. Install peony rings or stakes in early spring before the stems grow tall. Remove spent flowers after blooming to keep the plant looking tidy. Leave the foliage in place until it yellows in fall. The leaves produce energy that the plant stores for next year’s growth. In fall, cut all old leaves to the ground and destroy them rather than adding them to the compost. Wisconsin Extension recommends this to limit botrytis blight and leaf blotch.
Red peony FAQ
What is the most popular red peony?
‘Karl Rosenfield’ is one of the most planted. The American Peony Society registry quotes older growers who called it the best red variety.
Which red peonies bloom first?
‘Buckeye Belle’, ‘Red Charm’, and ‘Cherry Hill’ are all listed as early or very early. Fernleaf peony also blooms ahead of most garden peonies.
Do red peonies need staking?
Some do. ‘Félix Crousse’ has weak stems that need support. ‘Kansas’ and ‘Red Charm’ have strong or stiff stems.
Are red peonies fragrant?
Many are not. ‘Karl Rosenfield’ has no scent, and ‘Victoire de la Marne’ has an unpleasant odor. ‘Command Performance’ and ‘Diana Parks’ are listed as fragrant.
When should I plant red peonies?
Plant or divide them in September or October, with the eyes 1 to 2 inches deep.
References
Where to buy plants online
These nurseries ship well-rooted plants and stand behind them.
- Nature Hills Nursery: the largest online nursery in the US
- Plant Addicts: perennials, shrubs, and trees with a plant guarantee
- Botanical Interests: flower seeds for the beds you plan yourself
Some links earn me a commission at no cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.





Leave a Reply